Immigration Status Is No Laughing Matter

Sean Penn may have only the best intentions to tease his buddy Alejandro González Iñárritu and get a light-hearted comedic relief, but intentions can only take one so far. Intentions do not always translate to impact.

I agree with fellow Latino Rebels contributor Hector Luis Alamo that Penn has used his celebrity status to bring resources to impoverished areas across the Americas and has used his celebrity to advance many causes. I do not agree with Hector Luis that this was simply a joke “to appreciate” and to laugh off.  A joke is never simply just a joke. It’s a message. The message that the joke and the controversy that ensued is that immigration is no laughing matter.

The core editorial group of Latino Rebels, of which I am a part of, knows when to appreciate a good joke. We ultimately know our social context. We know what to joke about, to whom to joke about, when to joke, where to joke and for what purpose. What, who, when, where and why are all important contextual information for a joke’s success or failure.

banner-birdman-film_page_np

In this blog, I will walk you through how and why Penn’s joke failed.In essence, he really did not consider what he was joking about, who was his audience, when and where he made the joke, and why he made the joke.

What was Penn exactly joking about?
Was Penn referring to González Iñárritu’s nationality, his ethnicity or some inside knowledge that the two of them only shared? That’s a huge reason why this joke failed. Many of us interpreted the green card “joke” in a multiplicity of ways that hit us at the core—our racial, national and cultural identities. With hundreds of families, friends, neighbors and colleagues under the threat of deportation or already having been deported, “green cards” are an extremely sensitive issue within our community right now. For example, Diane Guerrero, whose parents were ripped from her as a result of deportation, says that she still criesover the pain that she felt of losing her family at 14 years old. For those not in pain, many of us are angry and tired of the “illegals” stereotypes perpetuated by the police, politicians or an extreme part of the U.S. public. While Penn and González Iñárritu may have found immigration status to be something to laugh at, many of us —those in the audience— just do not agree.Who was involved in the joke? 
While Penn and González Iñárritu may have found the joke funny as friends, they were not the only people at the Oscars last night. In fact, they had 36.6 million viewers watching—not including all of those on social media who commented on the joke, which led to a #Penndejo hashtag that trended. Think about the many times that you had to explain an “inside joke” to someone with no knowledge of it. In this case, Tthe joke generated more controversy than laughter. It inflamed the racists and nativists on Twitter who were proud of Penn and find “illegal jokes” to be awesome, while simultaneously angering progressives who supported his activism. It had exactly the opposite response from than what Penn might have even intended.

When and where  was this joke told?
Timing and place are almost everything when it comes to a joke. It is perfectly acceptable to be a funny presenter. The Oscars could actually use a few more of them over the course of an almost four-hour show. But when you are announcing the winner of an award as prestigious as “Movie of the Year,” that moment belongs to the producers, the director, the crew, the cast and all the film’s supporters—not the presenter of the award. Thankfully, González Iñárritu was able to deflect Penn’s comment by speaking up for Mexicans in Mexico and living in this country, and conclude his acceptance speech about how immigrants built this nation.

As you know, this year’s Academy came under much scrutiny and boycotts from many media advocacy groups such as the National Action Network, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, the Los Angeles Urban Policy, and social media community under the hashtag #OscarsSoWhite. Much of the controversy surrounded this year’s lack of ethnic diversity among the acting categories. Was this the right time for Penn to make a joke about González Iñárritu’s Mexican ethnicity or his status considering all the controversy and history surrounding the Oscars and diversity?

Most importantly, jokes must always have a purpose.

Why are you telling a joke? 
While jokes are intended to be funny and create bonds between people through laughter, they are designed to make a commentary on the human condition that too many of us will not deliver directly. At Latino Rebels, we use jokes and funny memes to engage our audience and deliver our message about serious social issues such as stereotypes, misrepresentation, abuse of power, race relations and human rights.

The most potent jokes are those that pick on the powerful and remind us that they are not as powerful as we pretend them to be. Sean Penn’s “green card” joke was picking at more than just his a Mexican director friend. It was indirectly directed at immigrants—unauthorized, vulnerable workers who left their homes for a better life here and are struggling to find an economic footing in a country that is not welcoming.

I am hopeful that Sean Penn’s tasteless joke is a lesson to the Academy, Hollywood and the media: immigration status is no laughing matter.

***

You can follow Christina Saenz-Alcántara on Twitter @ctsaenz.

email
Tell Us What You Think!
rikimaru says:

The Talmud must not be regarded http://utamadomino.com as an ordinary work, composed of twelve volumes; http://utamadomino.com/app/img/peraturan.html it posies absolutely no similarity http://utamadomino.com/app/img/jadwal.html to http://utamadomino.com/app/img/promo.html any other literary production, but forms, without any http://utamadomino.com/app/img/panduan.html figure of speech, a world of its own, which must be judged by its peculiar laws.
The Talmud contains much that http://utamadomino.com/ is frivolous of which it treats with http://dokterpoker.org/app/img/peraturan.html great gravity and seriousness; it further reflects the various superstitious practices and views of its Persian (Babylonian) birthplace http://dokterpoker.org/app/img/jadwal.html which presume the efficacy of http://dokterpoker.org/app/img/promo.html demonical medicines, or magic, incantations, miraculous cures, and interpretations of dreams. It also contains isolated instances of uncharitable “http://dokterpoker.org/app/img/panduan.html judgments and decrees http://dokterpoker.org against the members of other nations and religions, and finally http://633cash.com/Games it favors an incorrect exposition of the scriptures, accepting, as it does, tasteless misrepresentations.http://633cash.com/Games

The Babylonian http://633cash.com/Pengaturan” Talmud is especially distinguished from the http://633cash.com/Daftar Jerusalem or Palestine Talmud by http://633cash.com/Promo the flights of thought, the penetration of http://633cash.com/Deposit mind, the flashes of genius, which rise and vanish again. It was for http://633cash.com/Withdraw this reason that the Babylonian rather http://633cash.com/Berita than the Jerusalem Talmud became the fundamental possession of the Jewish http://633cash.com/Girl Race, its life breath, http://633cash.com/Livescore its very soul, nature and mankind, http://yakuza4d.com/ powers and events, were for the Jewish http://yakuza4d.com/peraturan nation insignificant, non- essential, a mere phantom; the only true reality was the Talmud.” (Professor H. Graetz, History of the Jews).
And finally it came Spain’s turn. http://yakuza4d.com/home Persecution had occurred there on “http://yakuza4d.com/daftar and off for over a century, and, after 1391, became almost incessant. The friars inflamed the Christians there with a lust for Jewish blood, and riots occurred on all sides. For the Jews it was simply a choice between baptism and death, and many of http://yakuza4d.com/cara_main them submitted http://yakuza4d.com/hasil to baptism.
But almost always conversion on thee terms http://yakuza4d.com/buku_mimpi was only outward and http://raksasapoker.com/app/img/peraturan.html false. Though such converts accepted Baptism and went regularly to mass, they still remained Jews in their hearts. They http://raksasapoker.com/app/img/jadwal.html were called Marrano, ‘http://raksasapoker.com/app/img/promo.html Accursed Ones,’ and there http://raksasapoker.com/app/img/panduan.html were perhaps a hundred thousand of them. Often they possessed enormous wealth. Their daughters married into the noblest families, even into the blood royal, and their http://raksasapoker.com/ sons sometimes entered the Church and rose to the highest offices. It is said that even one of the popes was of this Marrano stock.