UPDATE, MARCH 18: Due to the COVID-19 crisis, the March 29 primary in Puerto Rico is being rescheduled.
SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — For a while, it seemed like the Puerto Rico delegates being decided in the March 29 Democratic primary were going to be split between Bernie Sanders, Joe Biden and Mike Bloomberg. As discussed earlier in Latino Rebels, Bloomberg’s pro-statehood stance had captivated the attention of enough primary voters to make the billionaire a force to be reckoned with on the island.
However, Bloomberg is now out of the race, declaring his support for Biden. So where are those Puerto Rican Democratic votes going now? The obvious answer would be Biden, but some voters we spoke to this weekend would disagree.
These are all comments made by former (and politically influential) Bloomberg supporters who wanted to remain anonymous:
“I was pretty disgusted by how the populares [the island’s pro-commonwealth party] persuaded Biden to not support statehood fully. I will sit out this primary even if it means not voting in this presidential cycle.”
“After Kamala [Harris] dropped out and when Bloomberg did the same, I received calls from a couple of Biden people recruiting me to the cause, but I haven’t made my mind yet. I know a couple of more progressive leaning folks who supported Bloomberg because of the statehood thing and now will support Bernie. I haven’t decided yet.”
“The Biden people have been recruiting people to their side hard. I have to admit that the bipartisan surrogate group they unveiled was impressive, but I was turned off by some of the people in that group. [Senate majority leader] Carmelo [Ríos Santiago] has voted in favor of some pretty Republican measures, and AGP [Alejandro García Padilla] was one of the worst governors ever.”
Having said that, it looks like Biden will still benefit the most from Bloomberg’s withdrawal.
Conversations with various Bloomberg supporters can be summarized by the following tweet:
Espero que todos los que creen en la estadidad para #PuertoRico y saben que esta carrera para ser el #DemocraticPrimary winner está entre Bernie y Biden, se recuerden que Carmen Yulín (enemiga de la estadidad) es co-chair de la campaña 2020 de Bernie.
— Elisa Muñoz (@elisadmmunoz) March 8, 2020
“I hope that all of you who support statehood for Puerto Rico and that the winner of this upcoming Democratic primary is between Bernie and Biden should remember that [San Juan mayor] Carmen Yulín [Cruz], an enemy of statehood, is Bernie’s 2020 campaign co-chair.”
A Yulín Cruz Problem?
There is no doubt that Bernie supporters are the most passionate base out there, and Puerto Rico is no exception. Everyone we spoke to, whether they supported Bernie or not, felt the same way. Maybe Tuesday’s campaign office opening in Condado will be a good opportunity to gauge the level of excitement for Sanders in Puerto Rico?
But campaigns are not won on passion alone, and the Sanders campaign seems to have recently ruffled some feathers.
Some Bernie supporters we spoke to were not happy at all with the recent comments made by Mayor Yulín Cruz that sarcastically asked who the “so-called Democrats who support statehood” would support after Bloomberg’s withdrawal from the race.
Con el retiro de Bloomberg los llamados demócratas estadistas han perdido su candidato. Me imagino ahora apoyarán al candidato que más se parece a Bloomberg de los que quedan.
— Carmen Yulín Cruz (@CarmenYulinCruz) March 4, 2020
“Those are the kinds of comments that make me roll my eyes and question why the Bernie campaign picked Yulín in the first place. She is known for improvising and sometimes alienating people. We don’t need that right now,” a Bernie volunteer based in Puerto Rico told us.
Si había alguna posibilidad que un estadista se uniera a la campaña de tu candidato… felicidades! La tornaste en 0% y los mandaste directo a Biden. Eres la mejor embajadora de Biden en la isla.
— Gabriela (@gabby_f_m) March 4, 2020
“If there was a possibility that a pro-statehooder would have joined your candidate’s campaign, congratulations! That turnout will now be 0%, and you sent them directly to Biden. You are the island’s best Biden ambassador,” @gabby_f_m tweeted to Yulín Cruz’s Twitter profile.
Some influential Sanders supporters in Puerto Rico tend to agree.
“We could have gained the support of some pro-statehooders after the withdrawal by Warren and Bloomberg, but I feel that ship has mostly sailed now,” another Bernie supporter based in Puerto Rico told us. “Some people I’ve spoken to will prefer to stay at home instead of supporting Bernie after what she said.”
A couple of Warren and Bloomberg supporters echoed that sentiment.
“I believe Bernie has been openly anti-colony while we don’t even know how Biden feels about that; however, I don’t feel like rewarding a campaign that openly mocks statehood supporters. I much rather stay home”, said a former Bloomberg supporter.
“People think a switch from Warren to Bernie is the most natural thing to do. It’s not that simple in Puerto Rico at least,” said a Warren supporter still undecided on whom to vote for.
Bernie’s stance on status seems to have affected him a bit as well.
Aquí otra razón por la cual no podría apoyar a Bernie Sanders y es por lo que he señalado antes, ha abierto las puertas para otra fórmula bajo el ELA— previniendo así la descolonización de Puerto Rico. No lo digo yo, lo dice el ex representante del PPD, Jorge Colberg Toro. pic.twitter.com/FaVq58Qxtw
— Joshua Manuel Bonet (@joshuabonetpr) February 23, 2020
“Here is another reason why I could not support Bernie Sanders, something that I have pointed out before. He has opened the doors for another formula under the ELA [Commonwealth], in essence preventing Puerto Rico’s decolonization. I am not the only one saying it. Former PPD representative Jorge Colberg Toro says it too,” pro-statehood Democrat @joshuabonetpr tweeted.
And Then There Are These Tweets
As this tweet explains, in response to Ríos Biden press conference, which shows the Biden Puerto Rico team and how it is a combination of statehooders and those who support the status quo.
Wowww Carmelo; esto es inverosímil e inexplicable…. un estadista 100% no avalaría estas dos personas allí. Los 2 representan lo mismo que tanto repudiamos… colonialismo. Yo estando allí; me hubiese parado, hago el reclamo a viva voz y me largo! Por principio
— Ismael Rivera (@isrive) March 6, 2020
“Wow, Carmelo. This is bizarre and inexplicable. A true 100% statehooder would not endorse two of the two people there. Those two represent the same thing we completely repudiate—colonialism. If I were there; I would have stood up, denounce it loudly and leave, just on principle alone,” @isrive tweeted.
Others also weighed in about the Biden Puerto Rico press conference.
4 anormales!!! Wow!!! 2 PPD que ni deben estar pq ni ingles saben y Los otros 2 PNP(estadistas) o por lo menos dicen serlos pero dudamos de eso!! Busquen el pasado de ambos.. Eran pipiolos de corazon!!! Osea aqui en PR lo que hay es un bakanal politico!!!
— WesSant12 (@WesSant12) March 5, 2020
“Four abnormal people! Wow! Two PPD party members who shouldn’t even be there because they don’t even know how to speak English well and two PNP statehooders party members or at least claim to be but now we doubt that! Check out their past. A bunch of amateurs! This is what we call in Puerto Rico a political bacchanal!” another tweet said.
Lo siento… en mi mente no cabe que Populares Y PNP se sienten en una misma mesa. Como se ponen de acuerdo con la estadidad si tienen pensamientos diferentes. Si no crees en la estadidad, como un PPD forma parte de las primarias demócratas??? #WTF
— La_Sata_Azul (@LaSataAzul) March 6, 2020
“Am sorry but in my mind, populares and PNP cannot sit at the same table. How can they agree on statehood if they take on different positions. If you don’t believe in statehood, how is the PPD part of the Democratic primary. WTF,” @LaSataAzul tweeted.
Muy cierto Trump ganará en los USA??!!! Pero en Puerto Rico ??los PNP y Estadistas deben VOTAR por Biden para derrotar a Bernie Sanders. NO se debe permitir que los 51 Delegados representando a PR,sean para un Socialista CastroChavista. Respaldado y asociado de Carmen Yulín Cruz!
— R E Moscoso (@reneolympic) March 6, 2020
“It’s true that Trump will in the USA!!! But in Puerto Rico, the PNP and statehooders should vote for Biden so that Bernie Sanders loses. You cannot allow that 51 delegates representing Puerto Rico should go tot a Castro-Chavista socialist, who is supported by and is an associate of Carmen Yulín Cruz!,” @reneolympic said.
Then there is this response from @eliottricotti, who worked on the 2016 Sanders effort in Puerto Rico, which got 38% of the primary voters to Hilary Clinton’s 60%.
According to Ricotti, the 2016 Sanders effort was much more organic and ideologically diverse. Ricotti said that the local press treated it as such and that there were plenty of statehooders working on the campaign, but now the Yulín Cruz connection has discouraged some 2016 Sanders supporters to not support Sanders in 2020.
Por eso digo. La clave del 37% fue precisamente que el desprendimiento total de las estructuras locales permitió una campaña genuinamente orgánica e ideológicamente diversa. La prensa lo pintó muy distinto, pero habo muchísimos PNPs envueltos en el day to day de la campaña.
— Eliot S. Tricotti Mookarjee (@eliottricotti) November 14, 2019
Not Happy With Sanders Staffing Choices
Bernie supporters who have collaborated with the campaign since 2016 believe that the mistakes of the past are being repeated.
“In a primary contest that has been so close and in which you need every single delegate available, it blows my mind that the campaign spent months without official representation here,” a Sanders supporter said. “The first person they officially named was Matt Berg, someone who has never dealt with Puerto Rican officials, as the representative of the campaign before the State Electoral Commission (CEE, in Spanish). In 2016 they made the same mistake when they named Betsy Franceschini to the same position. Betsy was great, but she had never dealt with the CEE before. Everyone in Puerto Rico knows that you need to name someone with institutional knowledge and connections.”
The lack of Puerto Ricans hired by the campaign has also confused Sanders supporters.
“I saw Chuck Rocha say in an interview that they were spending resources reaching out to Puerto Ricans in Florida, but when I asked their people in Florida how many organizers were Puerto Rican, they said zero. So, out of the 14 organizers in Florida, none are from Puerto Rico,” said another Bernie supporter.
On @InTheThickShow, @Maria_Hinojosa and I talked about @BernieSanders Sanders and Cuba comments. I shared what @ChuckRocha of Sanders campaign told me in Nevada about Sanders' chances in March 17 #FloridaPrimary. This is what Chuck told me.
FULL SHOW: https://t.co/MtgjafdguR pic.twitter.com/fypPInstVt
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) February 29, 2020
A pro-statehood Sanders supporter also questioned why the official team in Puerto Rico was named so late in the game, and why all of them seem to be allies of Yulín Cruz.
“They named Arlene Payano as the state coordinator. The other people they named all have ties to Yulín. They are also sending two organizers from California. As if they couldn’t hire two people from here,” the Sanders supporter said.
[…] In addition, upcoming primary states like Ohio (March 17), Illinois (March 17), New York (April 28), Connecticut (April 28) and New Jersey (June 2) have a solid share of Puerto Rican voters. March 29 is the date of the Puerto Rico Primary. […]
[…] Puerto Rico Democratic Primary is on March 29, and the debate over whether Puerto Ricans (meaning, here and throughout, those of us on the […]