Missteps Mar Puerto Rico’s Response to the Coronavirus

Apr 15, 2020
12:49 PM

Governor Wanda Vázquez at an April 5 press conference in San Juan, Puerto Rico (Photo via La Fortaleza)

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) — Puerto Rico officials say data that show COVID-19 cases on the island are much lower than in some U.S. states constitute proof they are containing the new coronavirus, but a series of missteps is raising concerns it could be more widespread than believed.

The U.S. territory is bracing for an anticipated peak of cases in early May as federal authorities probe a $38 million contract for testing kits that experts say are urgently needed but never arrived. Local officials, meanwhile, have favored televised discussions over press conferences in a situation that has angered many and drawn comparisons to Hurricane Maria.

“We’re basically operating blindly,” said Mónica Feliú-Mójer, spokeswoman for CienciaPR, a nonprofit group of Puerto Rican scientists who are demanding widespread testing.

Puerto Rico announced its first COVID-19 cases in mid-March, including one involving an elderly Italian tourist. Since then, officials have reported at least 51 deaths and more than 970 confirmed cases, with more than 1,400 test results pending. Some 9,200 people overall have been tested on an island of 3.2 million inhabitants, representing less than 1% of the population. Experts say the number is way below those of U.S. states with similar populations that the local government has used for comparison to say they have the coronavirus under control.

Utah, for example, with a population of 3.2 million, has reported 18 deaths and more than 2,300 confirmed cases, but it has tested more than 45,700 people.

Epidemiologist Fabiola Cruz said Puerto Rico has conducted 2,800 tests per million people, when the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends at least 6,000 tests per million to make accurate projections. Overall, the U.S. national average is 596 tests per 100,000 people, according to the COVID Tracking Project. Meanwhile, Puerto Rico reports 288 tests per 100,000, the lowest compared with any U.S. state.

On Wednesday, dozens of Puerto Ricans got into their cars and honked their horns as they joined a street protest to denounce alleged corruption and demand more testing amid a lockdown imposed March 15 and extended until May 3.

Health experts and economists say one of their biggest concerns is that Puerto Rico officials are using the limited data to estimate the peak of cases and implement a lockdown that has crippled a frail economy amid a 13-year recession as the island struggles to recover from Maria and a series of strong earthquakes.

Economist Jose Caraballo estimates the current unemployment rate at 37%, and said widespread testing is needed to stop the pandemic and eventually reopen businesses. The island’s Department of Labor has said it is receiving 10,000 unemployment claims a day.

Experts also worry the island’s anemic health sector can’t properly prepare if officials don’t know how many cases they’re truly facing.

“We have an uninformed strategy,” said Feliú-Mójer, noting that the island’s governor recently claimed her administration is controlling the curve of contagion. “Puerto Rico really does not have sufficient data to make that kind of assertion.”

However, Puerto Rico hospitals have more than 800 ventilators and roughly half of total ICU beds available and have not reported a spike in patients.

On Monday, Health Secretary Lorenzo González announced that officials would be distributing 200,000 rapid testing kits, acknowledging that the government needs at least 21,000 test results for a solid model. That is more than double what the government has reported.

“We are fighting to obtain testing kits,” said González, who became the island’s health secretary two weeks ago and noted that Puerto Rico is competing with dozens of countries amid the pandemic.

Meanwhile, newly appointed state epidemiologist David Capó said testing is currently reserved only for those who show symptoms and need it the most.

While the call for widespread testing grows stronger, federal and local authorities and Puerto Rico legislators are investigating a $38 million government contract to buy one million testing kits that was recently canceled amid intense scrutiny. The contract was made with Apex General Contractors, a small Puerto Rico construction company that said it would source the kits from Promedical, a manufacturing company in Australia. Promedical issued a statement to The Associated Press saying it had not been in conversation or entered into a contract with Apex, adding that it sells rapid test kits to approved distributors for less than half the value identified by Apex.

While Puerto Rico’s government recuperated its deposit, critics say it lost important time to secure testing kits elsewhere.

“This is something we have to keep investigating,” Rep. Juan Oscar Morales, a member of the governor’s party, told reporters on Tuesday.

While Puerto Rico has been praised for implementing a lockdown in mid-March that officials say has helped curbed the number of coronavirus cases, the government didn’t start contact tracing until nearly three weeks after the first case was reported, and it still has not publicized the location of hundreds of positive cases. A coalition of mayors awaiting that information said it would go to court to obtain that data, although González said Wednesday the details would soon be shared once mayors sign documents acknowledging certain information is private.

The health department also is trying to regain its footing after seeing three health secretaries in the span of two weeks last month, with the first secretary resigning after the governor criticized how he handled the coronavirus crisis.

Fearful that Puerto Rico’s government is not doing enough, the mayors of some towns are taking their own protective measures.

Luis Javier Hernández, mayor of the central mountain town of Villalba, decided to close the town’s borders and initiate its own contact tracing with the help of Cruz, the epidemiologist. They have been the ones informing the health department about cases, instead of the other way around, with Hernández accusing the central government of leaving towns to fend for themselves and of keeping them in the dark regarding COVID-19 statistics.

“Ever since Hurricane María, we learned we cannot wait on anyone,” he said. “I thought the government would have learned from that situation.”