The Dumbest Apology Ever From Indy Star About Racist Immigration Cartoon

Nov 22, 2014
9:34 PM

So just 26 hours after the Indy Star published this editorial cartoon on its Facebook site….


…the social media backlash was so harsh (are you surprised?), here is what the newspaper’s executive editor wrote this afternoon:

On Friday, we posted a Gary Varvel cartoon at that offended a wide group of readers.

Many of them labeled it as racist. Gary did not intend to be racially insensitive in his attempt to express his strong views about President Barack Obama’s decision to temporarily prevent the deportation of millions of immigrants living and working illegally in the United States.

But we erred in publishing it.

The cartoon depicted an immigrant family climbing through a window of a white family’s home as Thanksgiving dinner was served. I was uncomfortable with the depiction when I saw it after it was posted. We initially decided to leave the cartoon posted to allow readers to comment and because material can never truly be eliminated once it is circulating on the web. But we are removing the cartoon from the opinion section of our website, as well as an earlier version posted on Facebook that showed one character with a mustache.

This action is not a comment on the issue of illegal immigration or a statement about Gary’s right to express his opinions strongly. We encourage and support diverse opinion. But the depictions in this case were inappropriate; his point could have been expressed in other ways.

Cartoons are seldom intended to be read literally. And Gary did not intend this one to be viewed that way. He intended to illustrate the view of many conservatives and others that the president’s order will encourage more people to pour into the country illegally.

The illegal immigration issue evokes strong opinions and emotions. And it’s important to encourage a vigorous public debate on issues of this magnitude, but with respectful discourse. That is what we believe at IndyStar and that is what we will continue to do – to publish views from all sides as we explore the important issues that will define the future of our nation, state and city.

This perhaps one of the dumbest “apologies” ever. It’s never the fault of the people who created the content. Here’s a thought: who thought this was a good idea to publish? Why did it get to where it got, which is that the cartoon was created and was published? Also, their initial reaction was to just remove a mustache? And spare us the patronizing lectures because this “apology” only confirms the bigger issue here: fear of change.