In an exchange at a February 16 Manhattan Community Board 11 meeting that is publicly available, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said he would not support a statehood bill for Puerto Rico.
The exchange, first reported by El Nuevo Día, was part of the meeting’s question and answer session. Manhattan CB 11 member Andrew Padilla was asking about tax havens for wealthy individuals (Act 22) in Puerto Rico, and Schumer ended his comments by saying the following about possible statehood bills being supported by Rep. Ritchie Torres (D-NY) and Bronx Borough President Ruben Díaz, Jr.
“I don’t agree with them. I am not going to support their statehood bill until we straighten Puerto Rico out,” Schumer said.
Schumer’s comments about the statehood bill appear at the end of this clip from the February 16 meeting:
Last Sunday, Puerto Rico governor and pro-statehood advocate Pedro Pierluisi announced that statehood bills would be presented in Congress by the middle of March, explaining that he hopes that the bills would have “considerable support” on Capitol Hill. Latino Rebels reached out to the governor’s office for comment about what Schumer said on February 16. As of this posting, it has yet to receive an answer from Pierluisi or La Fortaleza.
In December, Schumer told El Nuevo Día that the November 3 plebiscite where statehood won with close to 53% of the vote “did not reflect the strong consensus required to advance a pro-statehood bill” and that “he is waiting for an agreement on a ‘fair’ process on the island.”
Before Schumer made his comments about the statehood bill during the February 16 meeting, he also said the following about former Puerto Rico governor Ricardo Rosselló and his support of tax havens:
“I called up Rosselló the governor and screamed at him when he did that thing. I said, ‘You don’t let the wealthy get an escape route to not pay taxes,” Schumer said. “That was gross. But now there’s a new legislature and everything else, and we’re going to get better people on the PROMESA board. We’ll get rid of the PROMESA board. And we are now giving Puerto Rico more help.”
“We ought to tell that governor none of this bullshit when you let millionaires and billionaires escape,” Schumer added later in the clip, not clarifying if he meant former governor Rosselló or current governor Pierluisi. “And I’ve told him that, and maybe this is a good idea… maybe we should put something, they don’t get the money unless they rescind that thing.”
In addition, Schumer praised the work of Rep. Nydia Velázquez (D-NY), calling her one of his best friends and saying that he gave her the nickname “la luchadora.” Along with Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), Velázquez is the co-sponsor of a self-determination bill that would “prompt Puerto Rico’s Legislature to create a Status Convention whose delegates would be elected by Puerto Rican voters. This body would develop a long-term solution for Puerto Rico’s status, be that statehood, independence, free association or any option other than the current territorial arrangement.”
UPDATE, February 20
The official Twitter government account of Pierluisi tweeted out the following in response to Schumer:
I look forward to a productive discussion. The American citizens of Puerto Rico deserve no less than equal treatment. It is as simple as that. (2/2)
— Gobernador Pierluisi (@GovPierluisi) February 20, 2021
After those tweets, Pierluisi’s personal account tweeted this:
Statehood is the solution, everything else falls short. @SenSchumer, Puerto Ricans deserve a seat at the table to end inequality. Time to turn words into action, the greatest democracy in the world must listen to its citizens in Puerto Rico. https://t.co/Qn2F95lKe0
— Pedro R. Pierluisi (@pedropierluisi) February 20, 2021
Julio Ricardo Varela is founder and publisher of Latino Rebels, part of Futuro Media. He tweets from @julito77.
This really stinks. When the Dems needed the Latino vote they promised statehood. Now they are backing away. Dems or Repugs, whats the diff??
How many times do the people of the island have to vote for Statehood? How many times have the politicians of both parties promised action on statehood? Yet, the reality still stands-Puerto Rico is still being colonized by the United States- its natural resources have abused by military live fire exercises in the past, it’s people used for medical experimentation in the past- its economy abused by hedge funds abusers, now it’s land purchased by tax evading rich people. The world is distracted by many problems, but this self inflicted genocide of a people is unreal. Politicians beg for the vote, get it and turn their backs. People need to wake up to reality happening in our backyard. No need to travel to Mars to find life. Go to Puerto Rico and save lives…..
[…] to come about that, especially if more Democrats united around the bill. Earlier this year, Schumer emphatically indicated that he would not support a statehood bill, although since then he has toned down his […]
[…] February 16, during a recent virtual town hall meeting, Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY) expressed his opposition to a bill proposing the admission of […]
Odd that someone from New York would object to citizens of what would be the 31st state in terms of population having a voice unless they “straighten out”– as if NY was all squared away? Really? Puerto Ricans have fought in every war from the war of independence on. It’s time to give them an equal voice in Congress, end the Jones Act, and allow them bilingualism.
[…] Latino Rebels asked Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) —who has said in the past that he doesn’t support any statehood bill— about which bill he supports. He noted that there are two bills about Puerto Rico in Congress, […]
[…] isn’t pressing the issue and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer has straightforwardly rejected the Admission Act, citing divisions on the island and tax issues. And even the Self-Determination […]
[…] while many in the media and prominent members of Congress focus their faux outrage on the supposed “tax haven,” and other second-tier issues like […]