The Troubling Study on U.S. Latinos CNN Didn’t Want You to See

EXCLUSIVE: Download findings here.

It is a study that CNN declined to broadcast to the public: a 2012 Hill+Knowlton (H+K) Strategies online survey for the Latino Donor Collaborative (LDC), which concluded that a vast majority of non-Latino Americans have highly skewed and racist perceptions of U.S. Latinos.

The numbers are startling.

For example, one-third think that more than half of the country’s Latinos are undocumented and nearly 80% of non-Latino Americans think Latinos are involved in crime and gang activity.

Udocumented9

The report —prepared by Research+Data Insights, H+K’s research division— produced such extremely negative findings about U.S. Latinos, that both H+K and the LDC worked to get CNN to exclusively broadcast the data in May 2012. After two weeks passed, CNN declined to run the data because at the time CNN had policies against publishing results from online surveys, regardless of methodological rigor.

In response to several questions submitted to CNN about why the news network decided to not share the study with the public, a CNN spokesperson said:

We are offered opportunities to participate in things like this with some regularity.  Some we move forward with, some we do not.  It’s unfortunate they [the LDC] have chosen this tactic to get publicity for a poll that clearly they couldn’t find a home for anywhere.

The report was shared with only one other national outlet in early June 2012, but the findings were never broadcast because that outlet was planning to conduct a similar initiative during the 2012 election cycle.

Undocumented11

H+K and the LDC decided to create a synopsis of the findings and sent it, including the full report, to Latino Rebels. Charles P. García, a CNN contributor and LDC founding member, also released the synopsis (download here) this week at Hispanicize 2013, with the hope that the study can be discussed and shared with print and broadcast journalists attending the event.

“It’s actually real news that CNN didn’t consider it news that most Americans believe Latinos are criminals,” said García. “Perhaps some executives there are so desensitized with the likes of Lou Dobbs on CNN’s airwaves for so long, with his well-documented hate speech and conspiracy theories against Latinos, that they didn’t consider it news.”

The H+K study consisted of “an online survey among a representative sample of 1,500 non-Hispanic registered voters in the United States between March 15 – 21, 2012.” The company also conducted “two focus groups in each of four U.S. cities” (Phoenix, Houston, Charlotte, and Chicago). According to H+K, “one group in each of the four cities was conducted among lower-to-middle socio-economic status Anglo-Americans and the other group in each of the four cities was conducted among middle-to-upper socio-economic status Anglo-Americans.”

Online surveys are starting to become more standard procedure than the exception. After the presidential election last year, Steven Shepard of The National Journal addressed the issue. Superstar presidential pollster Nate Silver also concluded that online surveys were more accurate during the presidential election than traditional polling.

Nonetheless, many media outlets still question the methodology of online polls. As Shepard wrote:

Despite Silver’s findings, The New York Times‘ polling standards do not permit reporting of online polls because participants for these surveys are not randomly selected, and roughly one-in-five Americans lack Internet access. “In order to be worthy of publication in The Times, a survey must be representative, that is, based on a random sample of respondents,” according with the Times‘ policy, which was shared with National Journal. “Any survey that relies on the ability and/or availability of respondents to access the Web and choose whether to participate is not representative and therefore not reliable,” the policy reads.

David V. Iannelli, President-Global for Research+Data Insights, said his company’s decision to go with an online approach for the LDC survey aligned well with studies that focus on sensitive topics.

“There are benefits to online public opinion research methodologies,” Iannelli said, “particularly when it comes to sensitive issues such as race, ethnicity and sex about which respondents may be less comfortable revealing their true opinions to a live interviewer.

134750977-Hill-and-Knowlton-Strategies-Key-Findings-of-Hispanic-Issues-Research

The H+K/LDC synopsis presented three major conclusions:

  1. The majority of non-Hispanics overestimate the proportion of Hispanics in the US who are illegal immigrants.
  2. Misperceptions about illegal immigration amplify anxieties around negative issues.
  3. Non-Hispanic Americans do admire Hispanic traits, but positive messages are rarely captured in media coverage.

The initial findings that most non-Latino Americans have greatly exaggerated views about the number of undocumented Latinos living in the U.S. and associate Latinos with crime and gang-related activity are only two alarming findings from the research. Here are other examples:

  • 75% overestimate the proportion of Latinos who are in the US unauthorized.
  • More than 80% of non-Latino respondents associate Latinos with NOT having learned to speak English.
  • Nearly 80% think Latinos are a burden on the health care system.
  • 70% think Latinos are a burden on the education system.

In addition, the study also focused on how the media covers Latino issues. It concluded the following:

  • Among Latino issues covered by the media, the issue of immigration and the U.S.-Mexican border has he highest volume of negative coverage, with nearly twice the volume of the leading positive issue.
  • Even though the vast majority of non-Latinos associate Latinos with strong family structure, religious values, and being “hard-working,” these positive messages are rarely captured in the media.

It will be hard to dismiss what one of the world’s most respected global brands found in a study that is extremely relevant to the U.S. Latino population and the gross misperceptions it still has to overcome.

“Latinos are not criminals,” said García. “We are an integral part of America, making up the millions of teachers, soldiers, nurses, doctors, firemen and police officers who serve and protect us every day. It’s time for our community, which has the power to tip an election, to aggressively protect our brand.”

***

Julio (Julito) Ricardo Varela (@julito77 on Twitter) founded LatinoRebels.com (part of Latino Rebels, LLC) in May, 2011 and proceeded to open it up to about 20 like-minded Rebeldes. His personal blog, juliorvarela.com, has been active since 2008 and is widely read in Puerto Rico and beyond. He pens columns on LR regularly. In the last 12 months, Julito represented the Rebeldes on CBS’ Face the NationNPR,  UnivisionForbesand The New York Times.

6 comments
QueMeansWhat
QueMeansWhat like.author.displayName 1 Like

Wow. I don't understand how no one thought this was news. Oh wait, I guess if you are not Latino and 80% of non-Latinos are not looking at you like you are a criminal, can't speak English, a burden to health AND education system, then, yeah, it's not news. Ugh. 

jsinfonico
jsinfonico

Thanks for sharing the study!  Growing up surrounded by both cultures, I've noticed it's a two-way street.  Is there anything similar regarding the Hispanic/Latino perception of  non-Hispanics/Latinos?

DignityPeace
DignityPeace like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @jsinfonico All groups have certain stereotyped perceptions towards others, but the ones that @julito77 is talking about here are clearly the product of the media.  

jsinfonico
jsinfonico like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @DignityPeace  @jsinfonico  @julito77 Yes, I don't mean to downplay the study.  I only meant it in the sense that I'd love to compare the two. The media needs some work, that's for sure.  Luckily the internet has made it possible for smaller networks to share the important stories with us.

DignityPeace
DignityPeace

 @jsinfonico  @julito77 I didn't think you were downplaying anything.  I was just pointing out that the stereotypes of Latinos directed towards non Latinos are not as media impacted.  I am pretty sure that these perceptions would be highly and significantly correlated to media coverage. 

I think that's a good point about the internet as being an alternative source of information to be shared.  The last 7-8 years have seen large shifts in the public perception on issues such as immigration, same sex marriage, and even marijuana legalization.  I strongly suspect that the connections and information that people are making and receiving over the internet has a lot to do with that.  

DignityPeace
DignityPeace

"nearly 80% of non-Latino Americans think Latinos are involved in crime and gang activity."

 

Well if media were reflective of reality, this would be true.  

Trackbacks